Intro song: Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow! by Frank Sinatra
6. Jingle Bell Rock: Bobby Helms vs. Rascal Flatts
7. The Twelve Days of Christmas: Straight No Chaser vs. Relient K
8. Up On the Housetop: Pentatonix vs. The Jackson 5
9. Jingle Bells: Lauren Daigle vs. Glee Cast
10. Angels We Have Heard on High: Josh Turner vs. Josh Groban
Outro song: Mary, Did You Know? by Reba McEntire