Sweetheart Killers: Amy Fisher - The Long Island Lolita

Obsession. Betrayal. A gunshot that shocked the nation.

In 1992, 17-year-old Amy Fisher became infatuated with an older, married man—auto mechanic Joey Buttafuoco. But when his wife, Mary Jo, stood in the way, Amy took matters into her own hands. The result? A near-fatal attack that made headlines across the country and turned Fisher into the infamous Long Island Lolita.

But as the story unfolded, it became clear that the truth was far more twisted than anyone first believed. Was Amy a naive teenager manipulated by an older man, or a calculated would-be killer? And how did this scandal turn into one of the most sensationalized true crime cases of the decade?

Join us as we unravel the real story behind lust, lies, and attempted murder in suburbia.

🎧 Listen now—because love can be deadly.

🔗 Support the show & get exclusive content: www.patreon.com/OnceUponaCrime

📢 Follow for more true crime: 🌐 www.truecrimepodcast.com

#TrueCrimePodcast #AmyFisher #LongIslandLolita #TrueCrimeScandal #CrimeOfPassion #OnceUponACrime