Can Catholics be honest about the sins of their Saints?

For Catholics, saints are remarkable Christian witnesses worthy of emulation. But what happens when a saint or hero is found to have acted contrary to the gospel? Fanatic enthusiasts may try to explain it away, says Dawn Eden Goldstein, when they should be acknowledging and denouncing it. Goldstein reflects on the life and legacy of beloved English writer and Catholic apologist G.K. Chesterton whose writings have inspired millions of Christians, but include some controversial and prejudicial claims about the Jewish people.

Gloria and Dawn discuss why "othering" groups of people is so destructive, especially when it's done by our heroes–from the saints to the founding fathers–and how their cheerleaders can show love and appreciation for them through penance and reparations.

Support the podcast and access America's content with a digital subscription!

Links:

Dawn Eden Goldstein's address on why GKC's fans must reckon honestly with his anti-Semitism

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices